Life coach vs. Therapist who’s qualified to treat trauma?

Therapist vs. Life Coach: Why the Difference Matters (Episode 13)

Mary Beth FoxSelf-Awareness & Growth Leave a Comment

UnderstandingTherapist vs. Life Coach: Why the Difference Matters the Inner Critic 

When you’re looking for help, someone who promises to help you heal your trauma, change your mindset, or finally feel good enough can sound like exactly what you need.

What do you actually know about that person’s qualifications?

In Episode 13 of Not Good Enough Stuff, I explain the differences between licensed therapists and life coaches, why those differences matter, and what to ask before trusting someone with your mental health.

As a Licensed Professional Counselor, I want people to understand what the credentials behind someone’s name actually mean. You deserve clear information about their education, training, scope of practice, and accountability.

In this episode, you’ll learn

  • When you’re looking for help, someone who promises to help you heal your trauma, change your mindset, or finally feel good enough can sound like exactly what you need.
  • What do you actually know about that person’s qualifications?
  • In Episode 13 of Not Good Enough Stuff, I explain the differences between licensed therapists and life coaches, why those differences matter, and what to ask before trusting someone with your mental health.
  • As a Licensed Professional Counselor, I want people to understand what the credentials behind someone’s name actually mean. You deserve clear information about their education, training, scope of practice, and accountability.

Timestamps:

00:00 Intro
00:47 Therapist vs. Life Coach: What’s the Difference?
02:44 What Training Does a Life Coach Need?
04:36 What Does It Take to Become a Licensed Therapist?
06:42 Coaching Hours vs. Clinical Training Hours
09:22 Certified Does Not Mean Licensed
10:38 Who Regulates Life Coaches?
13:23 Licensing Boards and Professional Accountability
14:57 What Does Confidential Actually Mean?
16:21 Trauma-Informed vs. Qualified to Treat Trauma
17:42 Coaching and Therapy Are Different Services
18:50 Life Coaching Marketing Claims Worth Questioning
21:09 When “Therapy Didn’t Work” Becomes a Sales Pitch
25:02 Knowing About Trauma vs. Being Qualified to Treat It
26:28 Questions to Ask Before Hiring Someone
27:37 Know Their Training, Credentials, and Accountability
29:17 How Mental Health Professionals Can Request the Slides

A takeaway to sit with

Someone’s confidence in their ability to help you does not tell you what they are qualified to do.

If you already struggle with Not Good Enough Stuff, you may blame yourself when an approach doesn’t help. Before deciding you didn’t try hard enough, consider whether the support you received matched your needs.

Ask yourself:

What do I know about this person’s qualifications beyond what they promise?

Then consider:

  • What education and supervised training have they completed?
  • Can I verify their license or credentials?
  • Have they explained the limits of their services?
  • What happens if my needs fall outside their training?
  • Do I understand how my information is protected?
  • Who can I contact if I have a concern?

You deserve clear answers before committing your time, money, and trust.

What do you wish you had known before choosing someone to help you?

Resources & Links:

Read The Full Episode Transcript

In today’s episode, I want to talk about what does it actually take to become a therapist versus a life coach. Have you ever looked at someone’s bio and seen words like trauma-informed coach, certified trauma coach, inner child coach, or healing coach, or somatic coach, and assumed that they meant they were trained to treat trauma?

Or maybe you’ve seen someone promise to help you heal childhood wounds, rewire your brain, break trauma patterns, or finally heal what years of therapy couldn’t fix. Here’s the question I want you to ask. What qualifications does that person have to do that? I’m Mary Beth Fox, I’m a licensed professional counselor, and today we’re going to talk about something.

I think consumers need a lot more information about the difference between a mental

health professional and a life coach.

This is not an episode about life coaches being bad people. It’s not an argument that coaching has no value. There are coaches who are highly trained in coaching, take ethics seriously, understand the limits of their role, and provide a valuable service. My concern is what happens when the distinction between life coaching and mental health treatment becomes blurry.

Particularly when we’re talking about trauma, mental health conditions, childhood wounds, and just overall psychological healing. Because these professions are not interchangeable. And I don’t think consumers always recognize how the different education, training, regulation, accountability, and professional requirements can be.

What training is required to call yourself a life coach? Here’s the first thing I don’t think a lot of consumers know. You can call yourself a life coach without completing formal life coach training. There is not one universal government mandated educational or training pathway attached to the title Life Coach in the United States. You don’t have to have a particular degree or a degree at all.

You don’t have to hold a mental health license. You aren’t required simply by using the title Life Coach to have clinical training or supervised clinical experience. That does not mean that life coaches aren’t trained. Many are. There are voluntary professional coaching credentials and some require substantial education and coaching experience.

In fact, at the higher end of voluntary professional coaching credentialing, we’re talking about more than 200 hours of coaching specific education and thousands of hours of coaching experience. I’m intentionally showing you the higher end because I don’t want to compare licensed therapists with somebody who took a weekend course and then called themselves a coach. I want this comparison to be fair. But here’s the important distinction.

Those 2500 hours represent coaching experience. They are not 25 hours of supervised clinical mental health experience. So the words life coach by themselves do not tell you how much training someone has. That person could have substantial professional coaching education, or they could have no formal coaching training at all. That’s why you have to look beyond.

The title.

Now let’s compare that with my own profession. I’m a licensed professional counselor in Oregon and Mississippi. So I’m using my own license as an example. requirements do vary by license and by state. Becoming an LPC in Oregon requires a qualifying graduate degree and graduate level clinical education.

There is supervised practicum and internship experience while in graduate school. Then there is an extensive supervised clinical experience requirement. In Oregon, the pathway includes at least 36 months of qualified supervised clinical experience and 1900 hours of supervised direct client contact. And I want to emphasize direct client contact.

Those 1900 hours are not the total number of hours involved in becoming an LPC. They don’t simply include everything you did while working toward

licensure.

There are additional hours spent in things like supervision, documentation, consultation, training, and other professional activities. The 1900 figure refers specifically to the required direct client component with a much larger clinical training and licensure pathway. There are also examination requirements and requirements involving the state laws and professional rules.

Then you obtain state licensure. And getting the license is not the end of it. There are continuing education requirements, ethical and legal obligations, and ongoing regulatory oversight. So when you hear 1900 hours, don’t interpret that as it takes 1900 total hours to become a therapist. It does not. those are required.

Direct client contact hours within a much broader professional training process.

And that distinction becomes really important on my next slide of comparing a life coach with a licensed therapist. Not all experience hours are the same. this is where the numbers can become misleading if we don’t understand what they’re actually measuring. At the higher end of voluntary professional coaching credentialing, someone

May have 2,500 or more hours of coaching experience. That is substantial experience in coaching. But 2,500 hours of coaching experience is not the same thing as supervised clinical experience required to become a licensed mental health professional. Clinical training involves much more than simply accumulating hours talking with people.

Depending on the license and the state, becoming a therapist involves graduate clinical education, supervised clinical training, direct client contact, assessment and treatment, professional supervision, examinations, and other licensure requirements. And here’s something especially important when you’re comparing numbers.

When a licensing requirement specifies direct client contact hours, those are hours spent providing clinical services directly to clients. They aren’t necessarily the total number of hours someone spent completing their professional training. There can be additional time spent in supervision, documentation, consultation.

Trainings and other parts of clinical practice that is not represented in that direct client contact number.

So if you ever see somebody compare a coach’s 2,500 hours of coaching experience to a therapist’s required number of direct client contact hours and conclude that the coach therefore has more training, that is not an apples to apples comparison. The number of hours alone does not tell you what someone was trained to do. The better question is hours doing what?

Were they coaching hours? Were they supervised clinical hours? Were they direct client contact hours? what education came before those hours? What kind of supervision was involved? And most importantly, what did that training actually qualify the person to do?

Experience in one profession does not automatically qualify someone to practice another profession. On this slide I discuss how certified does not equal licensed. so here’s another distinction that gets confusing very quickly. Certified is not the same thing as licensed, like I said.

A certification or professional credential can absolutely represent meaningful education and skill. Some certifications are rigorous. But when you see the word certified, ask. Certified by whom? What did the certification require? How much education was involved? Was there supervised practice? What did the training actually prepare the person to do?

And does the person separately hold a professional license? A professional license is different. Licensure involves legally established requirements, professional standards, a regulatory structure, and mechanisms for complaints and professional discipline. So don’t assume because somebody’s bio has several letters after their name, that those letters represent a professional license. Find out what they actually mean.

And there’s another reason that this distinction matters that goes far beyond education. Who regulates this person? Who regulates a life coach?

If somebody is practicing solely as a life coach and does not hold a regulated professional license, there is not a mental health licensing board overseeing them simply because they’re a coach. There isn’t a coaching license for a state mental health board to restrict, suspend, or revoke. Now, a coach may hold a private professional certification or credential. That organization may establish ethical standards.

It may have a complaint process. Those things can absolutely matter. But a private certification or credential is not the same thing as state professional licensure. There’s also another category we need to acknowledge. Some coaches also hold professional licenses. Some might be a licensed counselor, social worker, psychologist, nurse, physician, or another regulated.

profession and also provide coaching. In those situations their professional licensing board may still have authority over aspects of their conduct, depending on their profession, the state, the circumstances, and what actually occurred.

Simply calling a service coaching does not necessarily remove every professional obligation associated with another license someone holds. So don’t only ask, are you a coach? Ask what professional license do you hold, if any, and who regulates you?

Ask, what governs my confidentiality? Who holds you accountable if it’s violated? If I believe you behaved unethically, where can I file a complaint? And what authority does that organization actually have? A coach may take confidentiality every bit as seriously as a therapist does. The question is not whether the individual cares about your privacy.

The question is, what legal and regulatory framework exists behind the promise of confidentiality?

So now let’s look at what does licensing board accountability actually mean. Why does that matter? Because a professional license is not simply evidence that somebody completed a particular educational pathway. It creates a system of professional accountability. As a licensed mental health professional, I’m accountable to a state licensing board.

Consumers can file complaints, the board can investigate allegations of professional misconduct, and when violations are established, professional discipline can be imposed.

Depending on the circumstances, a license can be restricted, suspended, or revoked. So think about what that means from a consumer protection standpoint. If a licensed professional harms a client through professional misconduct, there is a regulatory mechanism that can potentially affect that person’s ability to continue practicing under that license.

That doesn’t mean licensed professionals can’t harm people. They can. It doesn’t mean that every complaint results in discipline. It does not. And a professional license certainly does not guarantee that somebody is a good therapist. But there is a regulatory structure designed to establish standards and provide a mechanism for accountability when those standards may have been violated.

A license is not just a credential, it creates a system of accountability.

also want to look at what does confidential actually mean. Confidentiality is another example of why this distinction matters. If somebody tells you everything you tell me is confidential, I want you to ask what that actually means. as a licensed therapist, confidentiality isn’t simply a personal promise I make to my clients.

I practice under professional and legal requirements governing confidentiality and the handling of client information. A coach can absolutely promise confidentiality. They may have confidentiality provisions in their agreement with you. They may follow confidentiality requirements established by a private certification or credentialing organization.

And a coach may take your privacy extremely seriously. That’s not what I’m questioning. What I’m asking is, what professional, legal, and regulatory structure exists behind that promise? Because those structures aren’t necessarily the same. Think about what you may be sharing with this person. Your childhood, your relationships, your family, your trauma, your mental health.

potentially some of the most private experiences of your life. So don’t only ask, is this confidential?

Now let’s look at trauma-informed and how that does not mean you are qualified to treat trauma. This one is especially important. Being trauma-informed is not the same thing as being qualified to provide clinical trauma treatment. Trauma education can be incredibly valuable in all kinds of settings. Teachers can learn about trauma, coaches can learn about trauma.

Employers can learn about trauma. Parents can learn about trauma. That knowledge can change the way people understand and respond to somebody who has experienced trauma. But knowing about trauma does not automatically qualify someone to clinically assess or treat trauma. Clinical trauma treatment can involve assessment, diagnosis when applicable.

Treatment planning, psychotherapy, and specific clinical competencies.

So if somebody describes themselves as a trauma-informed life coach, that phrase alone does not tell you what they’re qualified to do. Ask what their underlying professional qualifications actually prepare and authorize them to do. Trauma-informed does not mean trauma treatment qualified.

I want you to understand that coaching and therapy are very different services. and this is why I don’t think this conversation needs to become coaching versus therapy. They’re different services. Coaching may involve goals, accountability, personal or professional development, decision making, behavior, or habit change. And

Helping somebody move toward desired outcomes.

Therapy may involve assessment, diagnosis when applicable, treatment of mental health disorders, psychotherapy, trauma treatment, and clinical risk assessment. there can certainly be areas where the conversations sound similar, but similarity in conversation does not make the professional services interchangeable.

Coaching can be appropriate and valuable. Therapy can be appropriate and valuable. The concern arises when somebody believes they’re receiving mental health treatment from a person whose education, training, or professional credentials don’t actually qualify them to provide it. Different services, different training.

Let’s look at life coaching marketing claims that are worth questioning. I want to talk about how many life coaches are marketing themselves.

one of the biggest things I want you to pay attention to is the language being used to sell you a service.

like heal your trauma, rewire your brain, heal attachment wounds, release stored trauma, heal your inner child, become trauma-free, break generational trauma, heal your nervous system, undo years of trauma, or promises that you can transform your life or heal something that you struggle with for years and a certain number of weeks. I want to be really clear here.

The use of one of these phrases by itself does not automatically mean somebody is doing something wrong.

Licensed mental health professionals may talk about attachment wounds, trauma, inner child work, or generational patterns too. What I want you to pay attention to is who is making the claim. What are they actually promising to do? And what qualifies them to provide that service? if somebody says they can heal your trauma?

What education and training do they have in trauma? If they’re talking about rewiring your brain, what exactly do they mean by that? What evidence supports the intervention they’re selling? If you’re promising to treat attachment wounds or childhood trauma, what professional qualifications do they have to provide that service?

And if they’re promising that their particular method can undo something you’ve struggled with for years in six weeks, eight weeks, twelve weeks, ask questions about that too. Especially when you’re hurting, because when you’ve spent years thinking, why am I still like this? Why can’t I fix this? Why do I still feel not good enough? Someone telling you, I know why nothing else has worked, and I know how to finally fix it.

can be incredibly compelling. That doesn’t automatically mean the service has no value. it means the bigger the promise, the more important it is to understand the qualifications and evidence behind it.

Here’s another marketing strategy that I am seeing more and more from life coaches. Therapy didn’t work for you. It’s a marketing claim worth questioning. And there’s another marketing strategy that I want you to pay attention to. I see versions of this a lot. Therapy didn’t work for you because therapy doesn’t get to the root. You’ve spent years talking about your problems and you’re still stuck. Traditional therapy doesn’t actually heal trauma.

Or some version of you’ve tried therapy. Now try this. And this is where I have a problem. There are a lot of reasons somebody can go to therapy and not get the results they want.

Maybe you weren’t ready to do some of the really difficult work yet. Maybe you understood things intellectually in session, but you weren’t ready to make changes outside of the therapy room. Maybe there were things you weren’t able to fully be open about yet. Sometimes it takes a long time before someone feels safe enough to tell another person what has actually happened to them or what they’re actually experiencing.

Maybe you stopped before there was enough time for meaningful change.

Maybe life circumstances made it incredibly difficult to engage consistently. Maybe the relationship with your therapist wasn’t the right fit. Maybe the particular approach wasn’t the right fit for you. There is an enormous difference between saying therapy didn’t help me.

But that’s very different from taking someone’s disappointment with therapy and turning it into evidence that therapy itself doesn’t work, particularly when the next sentence is essentially, buy my program instead.

And therapy doesn’t work. The first describes someone’s experience. The second is a much broader claim. And neither one establishes that a life coach is therefore qualified to treat whatever therapy didn’t resolve. If somebody is telling you that therapy failed you and then immediately presenting you their service as the thing that will finally heal you, notice something. You’re being sold something.

That doesn’t automatically mean what they’re selling is bad. It means you should evaluate the claim as a consumer rather than simply accepting the premise of the sales pitch. A coach should not have to convince you that psychotherapy is useless to explain the value of coaching.

What is outside your scope or competence? What specific training do you have for the concern I’m bringing to you? When do you refer somebody to a mental health professional?

Just like I don’t have to tell you coaching is useless to explain the value of psychotherapy, coaching should be able to stand on what coaching does well. Therapy should be able to stand on what therapy does well. if someone has to discredit an entire profession

To convince you to buy their service, pay attention. ask yourself why their service can’t be explained on its own merits.

And that’s very different language from legitimate criticism of therapy. Mental health care deserves criticism. There are therapists who are not good therapists. Therapists make mistakes. A therapist can be excellent in one area and completely inappropriate for another.

Not every therapeutic approach works equally well for every person or every problem. There are enormous problems involving access to care, cost, insurance, availability, and finding appropriately specialized treatment. We should all be talking openly about all of those things.

So now let’s talk about how knowing about something does not equal being qualified to treat it. Having a client with trauma is not the same thing as being qualified to treat trauma.

Knowing about anxiety is not the same thing as being qualified to treat an anxiety disorder. Understanding depression is not the same thing as being qualified to treat a depressive disorder. Learning about attachment is not the same thing as being qualified to provide psychotherapy. And this applies to me too. Having an LPC after my name does not mean I’m automatically competent to treat every mental health condition.

every population or every clinical presentation. Part of professional competence is recognizing where your competence ends.

If somebody comes to me with something outside of my training or competence, my responsibility isn’t to decide that because I’m a therapist, I can figure it out. My responsibility is to recognize that limitation and refer them to somebody who has the appropriate training. That’s important because I’m not saying therapists know everything and coaches know nothing. I’m saying that.

Different professional services require different kinds of preparation. And consumers deserve to know what the person they’re trusting is actually qualified to do.

Before you hire someone to help you heal, there’s a lot to think about. What can you actually do with all of this information? Ask questions. What are your professional credentials? Is that a state license or a private certification? Where can I verify your license or credential? What formal training have you completed for the services you provide? What did that training actually prepare you to do?

What happens if serious mental health symptoms arise? And after everything we’ve talked about today, I’d also ask, who regulates your professional conduct? What confidentiality requirements apply to our work together? if I have a concern about your conduct, where can I file a complaint? Those are reasonable questions. You have a right to understand the qualifications and accountability.

of someone you’re trusting with something this important. And pay attention to how the person responds. A professional should be able to tell you what they do. They should also be able to tell you what they don’t do.

Here’s the bottom line. A life coach can be very good at coaching. That does not make coaching psychotherapy. And a therapist having a license doesn’t mean they’re automatically the right therapist for you or qualified to treat every concern you could possibly bring into their office. Know who you’re hiring, know their training, know what their credentials actually mean, and know who holds them accountable. Coaching can be valuable.

Therapy can be valuable. They are different professional services.

Someone being able to say, that’s outside my competence, and I think you need someone with different training is not evidence that they’re less knowledgeable. Sometimes that’s evidence of professional responsibility. You have a right to ask before you trust someone with your mental health.

So the next time you see somebody promising to heal your trauma, rewire your brain, heal your inner child, or finally fix what years of therapy couldn’t, don’t just ask whether the message resonates with you. Ask, what qualifies this person to do what they’re promising me? What professional standards are they accountable to? What protections do I have if something goes wrong? Because you deserve information to make that decision for yourself.

If you didn’t know that there was this much difference between these credentials and training pathways for life coaches versus licensed mental health professionals, let me know. and if you know somebody who’s trying to figure out what kind of help they need, send them this episode.

And if any of you are listening and you’re a mental health professional and you would like for me to send you these slides, I will absolutely do so. Shoot me an email and I’ll be happy to send it as long as you give me credit and you do not alter my slides. Because I think this is very important information that people need and need to understand and have in order to make the best decision possible for them. And as always, you are good enough. You always were.

And you always will be.

Music attribution:

Music licensed through Soundstripe.

License code: CDAA5GJA2635SEHS

If this episode resonated with you, please follow the podcast, leave a review, & share it with someone who needs to hear it. Every share helps more people begin questioning the messages they never chose to believe.

Disclaimer: The information shared in this podcast is for educational & personal growth purposes only. It is not a substitute for therapy, mental health treatment, or medical advice, & listening does not create a therapist-client relationship. If you need support for your unique situation, please connect with a licensed mental health professional in your area.

Continue the conversation

Did this episode help you recognize a message you never consciously chose?

Subscribe to Not Good Enough Stuff on YouTube so you do not miss future conversations about the inner critic, childhood patterns, self-worth, relationships, emotional needs, and reconnecting with your authentic voice.

You can also support the podcast by:

  • Liking the episode
  • Leaving a comment about what resonated with you
  • Sharing it with someone who may need to hear it
  • Subscribing to the channel
  • Exploring the free resources available through The Inner Child Therapist

Every view, comment, and share helps more people begin questioning the beliefs they were taught to carry.

Share With Your Friends

0 0 votes
Rate This Post
guest
0 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest